TL;DR
Get kitchen staples and gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The Kitchn’s Ali Domrongchai tested 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week, looking for a substitute for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. She named Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese the closest match and reported that its four-pack cost less per sandwich than the McDonald’s item she purchased.
The Kitchn food editor Ali Domrongchai tested 12 frozen breakfast sandwiches from five brands over a week to find an alternative to McDonald’s Egg McMuffin, and chose Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese as the closest match. Her comparison also found a substantial price difference between the products she bought: the Jimmy Dean four-pack cost $8, while the McDonald’s sandwich cost $4.89.
Domrongchai said she set up the tasting because she likes McDonald’s Egg McMuffin but dislikes paying $4 to $5 for one and wanted a freezer option she could eat without making a restaurant trip. Over the week, she sampled sandwiches from five brands, including Trader Joe’s. The report does not identify all the products tested or provide scores for each one.
Her top pick, Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese, has an English muffin, egg, cheese and sausage—ingredients that make it similar to the McDonald’s sandwich. The products are not identical: Domrongchai noted that Jimmy Dean’s sausage includes chicken, and its egg is a scrambled disk. McDonald’s uses a whole egg with a hard yolk, according to her account.
Domrongchai described the Jimmy Dean sandwich as less greasy while still flavorful. She praised its juicy sausage, soft egg and gooey, sharp cheese. The price comparison in the report was $8 for four Jimmy Dean sandwiches against $4.89 for one Egg McMuffin. Those figures work out to $2 per Jimmy Dean sandwich before any other costs, compared with the price she paid at McDonald’s. The source says prices were accurate when published and may change.
A Lower-Cost Freezer Substitute
The taste test offers shoppers who regularly buy fast-food breakfast a specific frozen option to compare with a familiar menu item. Using the prices Domrongchai reported, the Jimmy Dean pack costs less per sandwich than a single Egg McMuffin, while also allowing buyers to keep portions at home and heat one when needed. That may appeal to people weighing price and convenience, though the report does not assess whether every shopper would prefer the taste or texture.
The comparison is useful as a personal product review, not a market-wide price survey. It reflects one editor’s tasting and the prices she encountered. Restaurant prices and grocery prices can vary by location, retailer, promotions and date, and the reported costs do not include any sides or drinks unless specified. Domrongchai also compared a standalone McDonald’s sandwich with a multipack from a grocery brand, so shoppers should check local prices before drawing a direct budget conclusion.
Jimmy Dean English Muffin Egg and Cheese frozen breakfast sandwiches
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sandwiches Compare
Domrongchai’s target was McDonald’s Egg McMuffin, which she described as an English muffin with sausage, cheese and a whole egg. The frozen Jimmy Dean sandwich follows a similar format but differs in its egg preparation and sausage blend. These distinctions matter because a close match in ingredients does not mean the two products are identical in flavor, texture or preparation.
The Kitchn has previously published a related comparison: the source report says contributor Kate had identified Jimmy Dean’s Sausage, Egg and Cheese Biscuit as a lower-cost option for people seeking a McDonald’s biscuit sandwich. Domrongchai’s newer test focused on English muffin sandwiches and included a dozen products. The article also discloses that The Kitchn may earn a commission if readers buy products through its links, and says it independently selects the products it features.
““I set out to find a suitable stand-in for the McDonald’s Egg McMuffin.””
— Ali Domrongchai, The Kitchn associate editor
Limits of the Price Comparison
The published account does not provide the names of every sandwich in the test, a scoring method, blind-tasting details or nutrition comparisons. It also does not establish that Jimmy Dean’s product will taste like McDonald’s to other consumers; the selection reflects Domrongchai’s preference.
The reported prices are tied to the products and locations she bought, and the source notes they were accurate at publication. The article does not specify a national average or how prices might differ across grocery stores and McDonald’s locations. It also does not give cooking instructions or storage guidance, so readers should follow the product packaging and food-safety directions.
Check Local Prices and Labels
The report does not announce a follow-up test or a planned update. Readers considering the comparison can check current prices at nearby restaurants and grocery stores, compare pack sizes and ingredient labels, and follow the heating instructions printed on the frozen sandwich packaging. The Kitchn’s article invites readers to share their experiences with Jimmy Dean’s sandwich, but no further results are included in the source material.
Key Questions
Which frozen sandwich did The Kitchn choose?
Jimmy Dean’s English Muffin Egg and Cheese was Ali Domrongchai’s top choice and her closest match for McDonald’s Egg McMuffin.
How many sandwiches did the editor test?
Domrongchai said she ate 12 breakfast sandwiches from five brands over the course of a week. The report does not list every product she tried.
How did the prices compare in the report?
She paid $8 for a four-pack of Jimmy Dean sandwiches and $4.89 for one McDonald’s Egg McMuffin. The grocery pack price equals $2 per sandwich before other costs, but local prices may differ.
Are the Jimmy Dean and McDonald’s sandwiches identical?
No. Both have an English muffin, sausage, egg and cheese, but Domrongchai said the Jimmy Dean sausage includes chicken and its egg is a scrambled disk. McDonald’s uses a whole egg with a hard yolk, according to her comparison.
Was this a formal or blind taste test?
The source describes a weeklong personal tasting but does not say that it was blind or provide a formal scoring system. The result should be read as one editor’s product review, not a guarantee of other shoppers’ preferences.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
